AI Has These Five Questions for Your CEO - Part 1: ChatGPT
I asked ChatGPT (and Claude) what five questions it would ask a CEO if it were brought in by the Board as a CEO coach and governance advisor.
The goal was to identify the questions most likely to reveal clarity, alignment, risk, and accountability.
Here are the five questions that ChatGPT would ask:
1. What are the three most important assumptions behind our current strategy?
Why this question matters
This question turns strategy from a presentation into a test.
Most Boards review strategy by asking whether the plan makes sense. But the better question is: what must be true for this strategy to succeed?
A strategy can look polished and still depend on assumptions that are weak, outdated, or untested.
What to do with the answer
Sort the assumptions into three groups:
Well supported
Needing more evidence
Potentially dangerous
Then decide what the Board should monitor.
The output should be simple:
What are we assuming?
How will we know if it is still true?
When should we revisit it?
Who is watching it?
That turns strategy oversight into an active process, not an annual ritual.
2. What are you most worried the Board does not fully understand?
Why this question matters
This question exposes the gap between what management knows and what the Board truly understands.
That gap is often where governance risk lives.
The aha is this: the Board may be receiving information without receiving insight.
The issue may not be lack of reporting. It may be the wrong reporting, too much filtering, too little context, or not enough time on the real issue.
What to do with the answer
Treat the answer as a signal, not a criticism.
Ask:
Are Board materials too shallow?
Is management filtering too much?
Is the Board focused on the wrong things?
Does the Board need better dashboards, education, or deeper discussion?
The fix may be fewer slides, clearer risk signals, better pre-reading, or more time on the issues that matter.
3. Where are we relying too much on past success?
Why this question matters
This question separates real strength from inherited momentum.
That distinction matters.
Some organizations are succeeding because they are still strong. Others are succeeding because the market has not punished them yet.
Past success can hide weakening strategy, changing customer expectations, emerging competitors, outdated capabilities, or technology disruption.
What to do with the answer
Test the CEO’s answer against external evidence.
Ask:
What are competitors doing differently?
What are customers starting to expect?
What technology could weaken our model?
What risks are not yet visible in the numbers?
What would a new entrant see that we may be missing?
AI can help compare internal assumptions with external signals and generate scenarios the Board may not have considered.
The point is not to be negative. The point is to avoid being surprised.
4. What decision are you delaying because it is difficult?
Why this question matters
This question reveals where hesitation may be turning into risk.
Most CEOs know where the hard decisions are: a weak executive, an underperforming business line, a technology investment, a culture problem, a succession issue, or a cost structure that no longer fits.
The aha is this: delay is also a decision - and delayed decisions have costs. They drain attention, confuse employees, protect poor performance, and reduce future options.
What to do with the answer
Assess three things:
Why is the decision difficult?
What happens if it is delayed further?
What does the CEO need from the Board?
sometimes the CEO needs challenge.
sometimes the CEO needs permission.
sometimes the CEO needs Board alignment before acting.
The Board’s role is not to interfere. It is to understand where support, clarity, or pressure may be needed.
5. What should the Board hold you accountable for over the next 12 months?
Why this question matters
This question forces priority.
CEO accountability often becomes too broad. Financial results, strategy, people, culture, risk, operations, stakeholders, and leadership all matter.
But when everything matters equally, accountability gets diluted.
The aha is this: the CEO and Board may not be working from the same definition of success.
A CEO can perform well against one set of priorities while the Board quietly expects something else.
What to do with the answer
Compare the CEO’s answer with the Board’s expectations.
Look for:
Where the CEO and Board are aligned
Where expectations are vague
Where the Board may be expecting too much
Where key priorities or risks are missing
What success should actually look like
The result should be a practical CEO accountability framework with a clear set of priorities, evidence, timelines and reporting expectations.
What These Five Questions Reveal
These five questions create a more useful Board-CEO conversation.
They help the Board understand the assumptions behind the strategy, the issues management worries are being missed, the blind spots created by past success, the decisions requiring courage, and the priorities that should define CEO accountability.
Used well, the answers become governance intelligence.
They give the Board and CEO a clearer view of what matters, what needs attention, and where alignment must improve.
Jim Crocker is an AI governance consultant and board director. He writes about what boards and senior executives need to know about AI at jimcrockerai.com. Here is Jim's LinkedIn profile.
Comments